Zhang Zhao (156–236), courtesy name Zibu, was a Chinese calligrapher, essayist, military general, and politician. He served as an official of the state of Eastern Wu during the Three Kingdoms period of China. Born in the late Eastern Han dynasty, Zhang Zhao started his career as a scholar in his native Xu Province before the chaos towards the end of the Eastern Han dynasty forced him to flee south to the Jiangdong (or Wu) region for shelter. In Jiangdong, Zhang Zhao became an adviser to the rising warlord Sun Ce. After Sun Ce's death in the year 200, Zhang Zhao played a key supporting role to Sun Ce's younger brother and successor, Sun Quan, as he consolidated power and his control over the Jiangdong territories. In 208, Zhang Zhao strongly urged Sun Quan to surrender to Cao Cao, a rival warlord, because he believed that they stood no chance against an impending invasion by Cao Cao. However, Sun Quan refused to listen to Zhang Zhao and instead heeded the advice of Lu Su and Zhou Yu. Sun Quan's forces ultimately scored a decisive victory over Cao Cao at the Battle of Red Cliffs in the winter of 208. From 200 until his death in 236, Zhang Zhao served under Sun Quan through the collapse of the Eastern Han dynasty and into the Three Kingdoms period after Sun Quan became the founding emperor of the Eastern Wu state. Throughout his career, Zhang Zhao was known for being a stern, uncompromising and intimidating figure who commanded respect from both his colleagues and Sun Quan. Despite Zhang Zhao's seniority and experience, Sun Quan passed him over twice as a candidate for the position of Imperial Chancellor in 222 and 225 as he believed that Zhang Zhao was so headstrong and stubborn that he would not be able to effectively lead the administration. Nevertheless, Sun Quan paid his due respects to Zhang Zhao as a mentor-like figure who saw him through his formative years to his accession to the throne.
Early life Zhang Zhao was born in the late Eastern Han dynasty in the Pengcheng State (), a principality in Xu Province centred around present-day Xuzhou, Jiangsu.(張昭字子布,彭城人也。) Sanguozhi vol. 52. As a youth, he was known for being diligent in his studies and for specialising in the clerical script style of calligraphy. He studied the Zuo zhuan and Chunqiu under the tutelage of Bohou Zi'an (), and was known for being well read in history. He was also a close friend of two other well-known scholars, Zhao Yu () and Wang Lang.(少好學,善隷書,從白侯子安受左氏春秋,博覽衆書,與琅邪趙昱、東海王朗俱發名友善。) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
When Zhang Zhao reached the age of adulthood around 19, he was nominated as a xiaolian (civil service candidate) to serve in the government. However, he declined the offer and chose to join Wang Lang in compiling an essay on the ancient use of taboo names. They received praise from other Xu Province scholars, such as Chen Lin, for their work.(弱冠察孝廉,不就,與朗共論舊君諱事,州里才士陳琳等皆稱善之。) Sanguozhi vol. 52. The essay contradicted the arguments of Ying Shao, another celebrated scholar from Runan Commandery (汝南郡; around present-day central Henan).(時汝南主簿應劭議宜為舊君諱,論者皆互有異同,事在風俗通。) Pei Songzhi's annotation in Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Sometime later, when Tao Qian, the Governor of Xu Province, nominated Zhang Zhao as a maocai (茂才; outstanding candidate) to serve in the government, Zhang Zhao declined the offer again. Tao Qian perceived Zhang Zhao's rejection as an insult, so he ordered the latter's arrest. However, Zhao Yu, who was serving in Tao Qian's administration at the time, managed to convince the governor to pardon Zhang Zhao.(刺史陶謙舉茂才,不應,謙以為輕己,遂見拘執。[赵]昱傾身營救,方以得免。) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Service under Sun Ce When chaos broke out throughout China in the 190s, many people living in Xu Province fled their homes and crossed the Yangtze River to take shelter in Yang Province (or the Jiangdong region) in the south. Zhang Zhao followed suit and moved from Pengcheng State to Jiangdong.(漢末大亂,徐方士民多避難揚土,昭皆南渡江。) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Between 194 and 199, the warlord Sun Ce conquered the territories in Jiangdong and established his own regime in the region. During this time, he heard of Zhang Zhao and wanted to recruit him as an adviser. After Zhang Zhao agreed and joined him, he was so delighted that he told Zhang Zhao: "Now that I have expanded my domain in all the four corners, I should treat learned and virtuous men with the utmost respect. I won't treat you in any degrading manner." He then appointed Zhang Zhao as a Colonel () and honoured him like a teacher.(吳書曰:策得昭甚恱,謂曰:「吾方有事四方,以士人賢者上,吾於子不得輕矣。」乃上為校尉,待以師友之禮。) Wu Shu annotation Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Later on, Sun Ce made Zhang Zhao his Chief Clerk () and promoted him from Colonel to General of the Household Who Pacifies the Army (). Apart from paying his respects to Zhang Zhao's mother and treating Zhang Zhao like an old friend, Sun Ce also consulted Zhang Zhao on various matters related to civil and military policy.(孫策創業,命昭為長史、撫軍中郎將,升堂拜母,如比肩之舊,文武之事,一以委昭。) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Receiving flattering letters While serving under Sun Ce, Zhang Zhao received several flattering letters from his fellow literati in the north. He faced a dilemma on how to deal with those letters. On one hand, he was afraid that if he kept quiet about those letters, Sun Ce would start questioning his loyalty. On the other hand, he was also worried that others would scorn him for being boastful if he revealed the letters.(昭每得北方士大夫書疏,專歸美於昭,昭欲嘿而不宣則懼有私,宣之則恐非宜,進退不安。) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
When Sun Ce found out, he laughed and told Zhang Zhao: "In the past, when Guan Zhong was the chancellor of Qi, he was called zhongfu. With his help, Duke Huan of Qi became a hegemon among the feudal lords. Today, as I have a virtuous talent like Zibu to assist me, isn't his glory also mine?"(策聞之,歡笑曰:「昔管子相齊,一則仲父,二則仲父,而桓公為霸者宗。今子布賢,我能用之,其功名獨不在我乎!」) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Sun Ce entrusting Sun Quan to Zhang Zhao's care In the year 200, before Sun Ce died, he entrusted his younger brother and successor, Sun Quan, to Zhang Zhao's care. He told Zhang Zhao: "If Zhongmou turns out to be incompetent, you may replace him. If there is no way to overcome the difficulties, you can gradually retreat back to the west where you will have no worries."(吳歷曰:策謂昭曰:「若仲謀不任事者,君便自取之。正復不克捷,緩步西歸,亦無所慮。」) Wu Li annotation Sanguozhi vol. 52.
After Sun Ce's death, Zhang Zhao led all of Sun Ce's former subjects to support Sun Quan and pledge their allegiance to him.(策臨亡,以弟權託昭,昭率羣僚立而輔之。) Sanguozhi vol. 52. Zhang Zhao also wrote a memorial to the Han central government to inform them about Sun Ce's death and that Sun Quan had succeeded his brother. He also wrote to all the key appointment holders throughout Sun Quan's domain to order them to continue performing their duties as before.(上表漢室,下移屬城,中外將校,各令奉職。) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Service under Sun Quan Assisting Sun Quan in consolidating power When an 18-year-old Sun Quan first came to power, he was so overwhelmed with grief over his brother's death that he spent his time mourning instead of taking charge of the regime established by his brother in Jiangdong. Zhang Zhao told him:
Sun Quan's biography in the Sanguozhi recorded that Zhang Zhao told the young Sun Quan:
Sun Quan heeded Zhang Zhao's advice. He changed out of his mourning attire, got onto horseback with Zhang Zhao's help, and inspected his troops as they assembled in formation.(乃改易權服,扶令上馬,使出巡軍。) Sanguozhi vol. 47. Sun Ce's former subjects accepted Sun Quan's leadership and pledged their allegiance to him. Sun Quan also appointed Zhang Zhao as his Chief Clerk () and ordered him to perform the same duties as he did under Sun Ce.(乃身自扶權上馬,陳兵而出,然後衆心知有所歸。昭復為權長史,授任如前。) Sanguozhi vol. 52.
With Zhang Zhao's assistance, Sun Quan managed to consolidate his control over the unstable Jiangdong regime left behind by Sun Ce. Apart from pacifying and winning over the people, he also recruited many talented and capable persons to serve in his administration.(吳書曰:是時天下分裂,擅命者衆。孫策蒞事日淺,恩澤未洽,一旦傾隕,士民狼狽,頗有同異。及昭輔權,綏撫百姓,諸侯賔旅寄寓之士,得用自安。) Wu Shu annotation Sanguozhi vol. 52. Whenever Sun Quan went into battle, he left Zhang Zhao behind to guard his base and oversee day-to-day affairs in the Jiangdong territories. During this time, Zhang Zhao suppressed an uprising by remnants of the Yellow Turban rebels.(權每出征,留昭鎮守,領幕府事。後黃巾賊起,昭討平之。) Wu Shu annotation Sanguozhi vol. 52.
Battle of Jiangxia
In the spring of 208, Gan Ning, who had recently joined Sun Quan, pointed out to Sun Quan that Cao Cao, the warlord who controlled the Han central government and most of northern China, was planning to attack Jing Province (covering present-day Hubei and Hunan) to the west of the Jiangdong (or Wu) territories. He also noted that Liu Biao, the Governor of Jing Province, was incapable of defending his domain, so it would be better for Sun Quan to seize Jing Province before Cao Cao could do so. The first step in Gan Ning's plan was to attack Jiangxia Commandery (江夏郡; around present-day Wuhan, Hubei), which was guarded by Liu Biao's subordinate Huang Zu.(寧陳計曰:「今漢祚日微,曹操彌憍,終為篡盜。南荊之地,山陵形便,江川流通,誠是國之西勢也。寧已觀劉表,慮旣不遠,兒子又劣,非能承業傳基者也。至尊當早規之,不可後操圖之。圖之之計,宜先取黃祖。祖今年老,昏耄已甚,財穀並乏,左右欺弄,務於貨利,侵求吏士,吏士心怨,舟船戰具頓廢不脩,怠於耕農,軍無法伍。至尊今往,其破可必。一破祖軍,鼓行而西,西據楚關,大勢彌廣,即可漸規巴蜀。」) Sanguozhi vol. 55.
Sun Quan approved Gan Ning's plan, but Zhang Zhao strongly objected and said: "The territories in Wu have not been completely pacified yet. If we proceed with this campaign, I am afraid there will be chaos."(權深納之。張昭時在坐,難曰:「吳下業業,若軍果行,恐必致亂。」) Sanguozhi vol. 55. Gan Ning rebuked Zhang Zhao: "Our lord has entrusted responsibilities to you as if you were Xiao He. If you can't even be confident that there won't be chaos under your watch, how can you expect to be like Xiao He?"(寧謂昭曰:「國家以蕭何之任付君,君居守而憂亂,奚以希慕古人乎?」) Sanguozhi vol. 55.
Sun Quan ignored Zhang Zhao and put Gan Ning in charge of planning and leading the campaign.(權舉酒屬寧曰:「興霸,今年行討,如此酒矣,決以付卿。卿但當勉建方略,令必克祖,則卿之功,何嫌張長史之言乎。」) Sanguozhi vol. 55. They emerged victorious in the campaign as they killed Huang Zu in battle and conquered Jiangxia Commandery.
Battle of Red Cliffs
In the late autumn of 208, Cao Cao launched a military campaign aimed at eliminating all forces in southern China who opposed him. He swiftly conquered Jing Province (covering present-day Hubei and Hunan) after the provincial governor Liu Cong surrendered without a fight. When Sun Quan's subjects heard that Cao Cao had gained control of Jing Province along with its tens of thousands of land and naval troops, they became fearful as they knew that Cao Cao's next target was Sun Quan's territories in the Jiangdong region.(其年九月,曹公入荊州,劉琮舉衆降,曹公得其水軍,船步兵數十萬,將士聞之皆恐。) Sanguozhi vol. 54. Sun Quan summoned them for a meeting and showed them a threatening letter he received from Cao Cao, in which Cao Cao claimed that he had 800,000 troops.(江表傳載曹公與權書曰:「近者奉辭伐罪,旄麾南指,劉琮束手。今治水軍八十萬衆,方與將軍會獵於吳。」權得書以示羣臣,莫不嚮震失色。) Jiang Biao Zhuan annotation in Sanguozhi vol. 47.
Some of Sun Quan's subjects, including Zhang Zhao and Qin Song, suggested that Sun Quan surrender to Cao Cao because, in their opinion, they could not win a battle against Cao Cao.(權延見羣下,問以計策。議者咸曰:「曹公豺虎也,然託名漢相,挾天子以征四方,動以朝廷為辭,今日拒之,事更不順。且將軍大勢,可以拒操者,長江也。今操得荊州,掩有其地,劉表治水軍,蒙衝鬬艦,乃以千數,操悉浮以沿江,兼有步兵,水陸俱下,此為長江之險,已與我共之矣。而勢力衆寡,又不可論。愚謂大計不如迎之。」) Sanguozhi vol. 54. However, Sun Quan ultimately heeded the advice of Lu Su and Zhou Yu and hardened his decision to go to war with Cao Cao. He also told Lu Su and Zhou Yu privately that he was deeply disappointed with Zhang Zhao, Qin Song and those who advised him to surrender to Cao Cao.(肅對曰:「向察衆人之議,專欲誤將軍,不足與圖大事。 ... 願早定大計,莫用衆人之議也。」權歎息曰:「此諸人持議,甚失孤望;今卿廓開大計,正與孤同,此天以卿賜我也。」) Sanguozhi vol. 54.(瑜曰:「不然。 ... 瑜請得精兵三萬人,進住夏口,保為將軍破之。」) Sanguozhi vol. 54. After making up his mind, he summoned all his subjects, drew his sword, slashed the table in front of him and said: "Any of you who dares to speak of surrendering to Cao Cao shall end up like this table!"(江表傳曰:權拔刀斫前奏案曰:「諸將吏敢復有言當迎操者,與此案同!」) Jiang Biao Zhuan annotation in Sanguozhi vol. 54.